Come in shorts and sandals and leave with a smile on your face! Island visitors enjoy the slower island vibes and life of the majority of Put-in-Bay’s downtown food and beverage choices. There are also many dining and restaurant choices, such as Casual Dining. ALL Bars The most popular island destination in Lake Erie, Put-in-Bay offers a wide variety of bars & nightlife.Bars The most popular island destination in Lake Erie, Put-in-Bay offers a wide variety of bars & nightlife.Come in shorts and sandals and leave with a full belly. Island visitors enjoy the low key and mellow atmosphere of the majority of Put-in-Bay’s downtown food and beverage choices. Casual Restaurants The most popular Put-in-Bay dining and restaurant choice is Casual Dining.Put-in-Bay is an ideal setting for a family getaway at one of the Island’s peaceful and modern campgrounds. Campgrounds Put in Bay Ohio South Bass Island offers several camping options for your enjoyment.